A Most Liked score is a number from 0 to 100 with two parts. The first is the business’s Google rating adjusted for its review count; the second is a Reddit bonus or deduction of up to 15 points. No business pays to be listed or to move up. Each ranking shows up to 8 businesses and the date its data was collected.
The formula in three steps
Edmonton Almanac calculates every score with the same three steps. The adjustment in step 1 stops a business with a handful of five-star reviews from outranking one with hundreds of strong reviews. The mapping in step 2 turns the adjusted rating into a 0 to 100 scale. Step 3 adds the Reddit part, which can move a business by at most 15 points.
- Adjusted rating: (v × R + m × C) ÷ (v + m). R is the Google rating and v is the number of Google reviews. C is the category’s average rating, and m is its median review count, kept between 50 and 300.
- Google score: the adjusted rating mapped so 3.5 stars equals 0 and 5.0 stars equals 100. An adjusted rating below 3.5 scores 0.
- Reddit bonus: plus 3 points per Reddit thread recommending the business, and minus 3 per thread advising against it. The total stays between minus 15 and plus 15. A business nobody mentions on Reddit gets 0, so absence is never a penalty.
The final score is the Google score plus the Reddit bonus, kept between 0 and 100.
A worked example with sample numbers
The numbers in this example are made up to show the arithmetic; they do not describe a real business. Take a category where the qualifying businesses average 4.4 stars and the median business has 150 reviews. Business A has a 4.8 rating from 600 reviews and two Reddit threads recommending it. Business B has a perfect 5.0 rating from 30 reviews and no Reddit mentions.
| Step | Business A | Business B |
|---|---|---|
| Google rating and reviews | 4.8 from 600 reviews | 5.0 from 30 reviews |
| Adjusted rating | (600 × 4.8 + 150 × 4.4) ÷ 750 = 4.72 | (30 × 5.0 + 150 × 4.4) ÷ 180 = 4.50 |
| Google score (0 to 100) | 81.3 | 66.7 |
| Reddit bonus | 2 threads × 3 = plus 6 | 0 |
| Final score | 87.3 | 66.7 |
Business A ranks higher because 600 reviews are stronger evidence than 30, even though Business B’s raw rating is higher.
Which businesses qualify
A business enters the scoring pool only if Google lists it as operating and it has at least 25 Google reviews. Its address must be in the city or a nearby town allowed for that category. Each ranking compares at least 10 qualifying businesses before it is published; a category with fewer is not ranked. The top 8 by score appear as entries, and the next 6 appear as runners-up. Ties go to the larger review count, and a business with several locations appears once, as its highest-scoring location.
Where the data comes from and how old it is
Ratings and review counts come from the Google Places service on the date shown at the top of each ranking. Google’s terms allow that data to be kept for 30 days at most, so the ratings are not stored long term. Reddit threads come from r/Edmonton and r/YEG and are linked from the ranking page. Every ranking is re-scored at least every 90 days, and the date on the page changes when the scores change.
What reviewers praise and complain about
Each entry lists what reviewers praise and what they complain about, side by side and always visible. A complaint appears only when at least 3 separate public reviews make the same point. Both are written as summaries of patterns in public reviews, never as quotes, and never as the site’s own experience. The team does not visit, test or receive anything from the businesses it ranks.
What the rankings leave out
Edmonton Almanac does not rank health, legal or financial services, because review stars are a poor guide to professional quality in those fields. Suburbs such as St. Albert and Sherwood Park do not get separate copies of a ranking. Their businesses compete inside the main city ranking when the category allows nearby towns. Paid placement, affiliate commissions and free products play no part in any score.
Limits of the method
The score measures how much the public likes a business, not an inspection of its quality. Google reviews can be uneven: some businesses ask every customer for a review and others never do. Reddit covers some categories, such as restaurants, far more than others, such as snow removal, so the Reddit part matters more in some rankings. The method does not include other review sites.
Is Edmonton Almanac legit?
Edmonton Almanac is a self-funded site that publishes its full scoring formula, its data dates and its sources so anyone can check a ranking. No business pays for a place, and the site takes no commission from listed businesses. If a number looks wrong, follow the steps for reporting a ranking error. The team will re-check it against the formula. More about who runs the site is on the page about who runs the site.